As many as 43.86% of employees at a social security institution in Central Java had worked for years without receiving a single promotion. This fact was revealed in a study published in the proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Banking, Accounting, Management and Economics (ICOBAME 2018). Dr. drg. Bambang Priyono, S.U., together with a research team from Universitas Stikubank Semarang, studied 110 employees of the institution to understand what causes careers to stagnate and what can prevent it.
This phenomenon is known as a career plateau, a condition in which employees feel that their opportunities for promotion are extremely limited. It is not necessarily because they are unmotivated or incompetent. Rather, it can result from increasingly flat organizational structures, intense competition, and a lack of meaningful development programs.
Two Factors That Make a Difference
The study identified two main variables as key factors: empowerment and quality of work life. Their effects on job satisfaction and career plateau were examined among 110 respondents working at the institution's branch offices in Central Java.
The results were quite clear. Effective employee empowerment was shown to significantly increase job satisfaction. Employees who were given opportunities to take responsibility, make decisions, and make meaningful contributions to the organization tended to be more satisfied with their jobs. However, the stronger influence came from quality of work life, which encompasses fair compensation, a healthy work environment, opportunities for development, and recognition of employees' rights.
With a regression coefficient of 0.650 for quality of work life compared with 0.339 for empowerment, the study demonstrated that how employees experience their overall day-to-day working environment is much more influential in determining job satisfaction than simply giving them additional authority.
Job Satisfaction as an Anchor
The most interesting finding of this study was not the direct relationship between empowerment and career plateau, but rather the role of job satisfaction as an intervening variable. Using the Sobel test with a bootstrapping technique, the researchers demonstrated that job satisfaction serves as a “bridge” connecting both empowerment and quality of work life with the level of career plateau.
“Work satisfaction becomes anchor or intervening variable. It works between empowerment and career plateau, and between quality of work life and career plateau.” — Dr. drg. Bambang Priyono, S.U., et al., ICOBAME 2018
This means that strong empowerment does not automatically reduce career plateau directly. It must first create job satisfaction, which subsequently helps alleviate feelings of career stagnation. The same pattern applies to quality of work life. The indirect effect of quality of work life on career plateau through job satisfaction was -0.3920, while the corresponding indirect effect for empowerment was -0.2788. Both were statistically significant.
Implications for Human Resource Management
In practical terms, these findings send a clear message to managers and human resource professionals: investing in empowerment programs alone is insufficient if it is not accompanied by comprehensive improvements in employees' working conditions and overall work experience.
When employees feel that their expertise is still valued, that the organization cares about their well-being, and that their work is meaningful, feelings of stagnation gradually diminish. Conversely, when quality of work life is neglected, even the most ambitious empowerment programs can lose their effectiveness.
The study also opens up a broader research agenda. The researchers recommend that future studies explore other variables, such as leadership style, job characteristics, and motivation, as predictors while continuing to position job satisfaction as an intervening variable leading to career plateau.
Ultimately, the figure of 43.86% of employees experiencing career stagnation is more than a statistic. It reflects how an organization treats the people who work within it every day.
Authors: Achmad Zam Zam Aghasy, DDS, M.Kes.; Hazra Alifia Muharam
Photo: Pexels