A titanium plate no larger than a human thumb. Thin, shiny, and designed to support a fractured jawbone. Yet when the plate is repeatedly bent during surgery to fit the patient’s facial anatomy, its surface changes—and that change can open the door for bacteria to settle in.
That is the central finding of a study published in F1000Research in May 2025 by drg. Bramasto Purbo Sejati, Sp.BMM, and a team from the Department of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery and the Department of Oral Biology at Universitas Gadjah Mada. The study addresses a question that has largely gone unnoticed: does mechanical damage to titanium miniplates during surgery directly contribute to bacterial colonization and implant failure?
A Plate That Ages Before Its Time
Forty miniplates were collected: some from patients whose implants had to be removed because of infection, and others consisting of new, sterile control plates straight from the manufacturer. Macroscopic photographs immediately revealed striking differences. In straight BSSO-type plates, the bridge area showed the most severe deformation—which makes sense, as this is where bending and twisting are most frequently performed during surgery.
More surprising were the contact angle measurements, a parameter used to determine how “hydrophobic,” or water-repellent, a surface is. Plates removed from patients had a mean contact angle of 89.6 degrees, compared with 72.3 degrees for the control plates—a statistically significant difference (p < 0.01). Paradoxically, more hydrophobic surfaces can be more favorable for certain bacteria to attach to and establish colonies.
“Mechanical damage caused by bending and twisting the plate alters the microstructure of the titanium surface, which in turn increases its roughness and hydrophobicity—two factors known to facilitate bacterial adhesion and biofilm formation.” — drg. Bramasto Purbo Sejati, Sp.BMM, F1000Research, 2025
Four Bacteria, Four Different Behaviors
The researchers then exposed the plates to four clinically relevant bacterial strains: Staphylococcus aureus, Streptococcus mutans, Pseudomonas aeruginosa, and Enterococcus faecalis. The results revealed a pattern that was both interesting and concerning.
S. aureus and S. mutans showed significantly greater adhesion to damaged plates than to new plates (p < 0.001). Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) images showed S. aureus colonies as dense clusters of cocci tightly attached to recesses in the uneven surface, while S. mutans formed long chains that spread evenly around the distorted areas.
In contrast, P. aeruginosa showed greater adhesion to the new control plates. This finding is not particularly surprising given the organism’s biology: as a motile bacterium, P. aeruginosa appears to favor smooth, hydrated substrates for initial colonization rather than rough, undulating surfaces. E. faecalis showed no significant difference between the two groups.
Anatomical location also played a role. Removed mandibular plates recorded the highest levels of S. aureus and S. mutans adhesion across all groups—consistent with the fact that the mandible is exposed to greater mechanical loads, undergoes more deformation, and has a more complex environmental setting than the maxilla.
When the Wound Opens, the Risk Multiplies
The study also documented a clinical phenomenon that is often overlooked: wound dehiscence, or the reopening of a surgical wound after the procedure. In several cases included in the study, miniplates that were initially covered by soft tissue eventually became exposed to the oral environment, where they came into contact with saliva, oral microorganisms, and mechanical forces generated during mastication.
Once the plate becomes exposed, the risk of bacterial colonization rises dramatically. This underscores the fact that successful initial wound healing does not guarantee long-term safety. Close postoperative monitoring is therefore crucial, particularly for patients with poor oral hygiene or suboptimal periodontal conditions.
Funded by BPI and LPDP, the study was approved by the FKG-RSGM UGM Ethics Committee and used data from Temanggung Regional Hospital collected between 2020 and 2023. Of the 651 miniplates placed during that period, 12 plates from 10 patients met the inclusion criteria—a figure corresponding to a 2% incidence of osteosynthesis infection, consistent with the range reported in the international literature.
Titanium Is Not the End of the Answer
This study is more than a technical report on metal and bacteria. Its implications extend to everyday surgical practice: how carefully clinicians handle plates during bending, when plates should be removed in high-risk cases, and whether alternative materials such as PEEK or selenium-coated plates—which have been shown to reduce bacterial adhesion—should be considered.
These questions are no longer merely speculative. There is data behind them—data generated from 40 small plates, four types of bacteria, and one simple question that turned out to have a remarkably complex answer: what happens to a titanium surface after it is bent?
DOI Source: https://doi.org/10.12688/f1000research.159954.1
Authors: Nanda Ayu, drg. Achmad Zam Zam Aghasy, M.Kes.
Photo: Freepik